Contents
So, you’re thinking about renting a car in Costa Rica. Good call—or at least, it can be, if you know what you’re doing. Because while having your own wheels is often the best (and sometimes the only) way to explore this wildly beautiful country, the car rental scene here has… a reputation. And not always a great one.
Let’s break it all down: what’s real, what’s exaggerated, and how to avoid driving straight into a financial pothole.
Why You Might Need to Rent a Car
Let’s start with the basics: Costa Rica’s public transportation system exists, sure—but it’s not exactly user-friendly. Buses can be slow, confusing, and rarely run on time. Schedules often don’t line up with tourist routes, and unless you speak Spanish (or love deciphering cryptic bus signs), you’ll probably spend more time waiting than exploring.
Renting a car gives you freedom, flexibility, and access to places buses simply don’t go—like hidden waterfalls, remote beaches, and jungle lodges that aren’t even on Google Maps.
Renting a Car in Costa Rica – The Price You See Is Not the Price You Pay
Here’s where the “scammy” reputation starts. Many travelers book a rental online for $5 a day and think they’ve scored a deal. Spoiler: they haven’t. That price? It’s rarely the full amount.
In Costa Rica, mandatory insurance and taxes are often not included in the listed price. Add those in, and that $12-a-day car can easily become $50–$80 a day.
Always make sure to:
- Ask for the full price including insurance and all fees
- Double-check what insurance is actually required (often, it’s liability)
- Get confirmation in writing before you arrive
Deposits – Prepare to Surrender Your Credit Limit
Another surprise? The security deposit. Most rental companies in Costa Rica will place a hold of $1,000 to $3000 on your credit card when you pick up the car. Yes, even if you already prepaid everything online.
This isn’t a scam—it’s standard practice here. But it’s definitely something you want to be prepared for. If your card has a low limit or you’re counting on that credit for hotels or tours, it might ruin your plans.
Big Brands vs. Local Rentals – What’s the Deal?
Companies like Payless Car Rental or Adobe Car Rental might seem like the safe choice. And in some ways, they are: new cars, English-speaking staff, and official policies.
But they can also feel corporate, rigid, and… kinda soulless. If something goes wrong, good luck finding someone who can actually help. It’s all forms, call centers, and “sorry, it’s policy.”
On the flip side, local car rental companies often offer a more human experience. Think WhatsApp chats, friendly staff who know your name, and way more flexibility. Some of them even skip the deposit entirely!
The trade-off? The cars might be older, with a few personality quirks (like mysterious rattles or radios stuck on reggaeton). But hey, you’re not here for a luxury SUV—you’re here for the adventure, right?
Are Costa Rican Roads Really That Bad? (Spoiler: No, but Also Not Like Home)
One of the biggest myths about Costa Rica is that the roads are all a mess and only navigable by wild donkeys or monster trucks. Not true. While we’re not exactly rolling on six-lane highways out here, most main roads are totally fine—and very much driveable without a 4×4 tank.
Sure, there are no Autobahns, and yes, roads love to zigzag through mountains, over rivers, and around cows. But unless you’re trying to reach some hidden jungle cabin 18 km off the grid, your standard compact car will get you where you need to go. A lot of travelers rent regular sedans and survive just fine—without ever needing to engage in off-road combat.
Now, if your idea of adventure includes unpaved roads, river crossings, and wondering if that mud is ankle-deep or bumper-deep… then yes, go for the 4×4. Otherwise? Chill. You’ll be just fine.
Renting a Car in Costa Rica – How to Not Get Burned
- Take photos of the car before driving off (all sides, wheels, interior)
- Ask about roadside assistance and what to do in case of an accident
- Keep copies of all documents and your rental agreement
- Don’t trust “all-inclusive” unless you’ve seen the fine print
- Be nice—but not naive. Even the friendliest agent isn’t your buddy when it comes to contracts.
Thinking About Hiring a Driver Instead?
If the idea of driving makes your palms sweat (or you just want to relax and look out the window), private transport with a driver-guide might be a better choice.
This is especially useful for families, groups, or travelers who want insights and local knowledge without dealing with directions or potholes.
But remember: you’re not just paying for a ride. You’re covering the car, gas, driver’s salary, meals, and accommodation. It’s more expensive—but for the right trip, it’s worth it.
We can help you arrange this kind of transport on GoExploreWith.me—stress-free, with friendly, bilingual drivers who know their way around the country and a good local soda.
Final Thoughts: Scam? Not Really. Confusing? Often.
Renting a car in Costa Rica isn’t a scam—but it does require some street smarts. Ask the right questions, read the fine print, and don’t assume it’s going to work like it does back home.
Do your homework, choose the right provider, and your road trip will be all pura vida and zero stress.
Need help picking the right route, rental, or ride? We’ve got your back.
One More Thing Before You Hit the Road…
Before you start planning your Costa Rican road trip playlist, don’t forget to grab our free eBook: “10 Hidden Gems in Costa Rica You’ve Never Heard Of.”
It’s packed with real-deal spots—secluded waterfalls, jungle trails, and coastal nooks—that are way easier to reach if you’ve got your own wheels.
No tourist traps, no fluff—just honest travel tips from people who actually live here.
Trust us: your GPS may fail you in the jungle, but this little guide won’t.
